mongo,
I don't shoot grease groove bullet in my Sharps rifles and you shouldn't either!
So I will address the pp loads only.
There really isn't enough information on your paper patch loads to offer too much help. Let's start with a few things I did notice and I'll list a few things I do that work for me in my rifles.
I see no mention of a wad? Type? Thickness?
The "no compression" thing bothers me some. Looking at the pictures, and I can't tell much, but I do see some variation in the seating depth or patch height, I'm not sure which. Something seems amiss there. Could be just the picture.
Large rifle primers. What type?
I have never used 2F Swiss, but I know people who do and it shoots well for them. I have always used 1 1/2 Swiss, but that's just me.
I loaded up to 105 grains of 1 1/2 Swiss in my Shiloh .45-90 (standard grease groove chamber) and it shot very well, but bigger cases seem to be a bit trickier to get top accuracy out of with paper patch. Some use a wad stack of various configurations or a grease cookie with a wad on top and on the bottom. I had to use a grease cookie in my .44-100 straight to get it to shoot paper patch bullets.
What bullet are you using for your pp? How does it fit the bore? Alloy?
You said you use a long drop tube. What I learned is that after a certain length it really doesn't matter. Mine is 14" and works fine.
You mentioned crimping the bullets. Was that the GG or PP or both? I found that it helps to close up the case mouth to a slip fit when loading bore diameter pp bullets and I have used Lee factory crimp dies to do so, but just to close up the case diameter not actually crimp the bullets. It does seem to improve accuracy, but I do it mainly for ease of handling, so the bullets aren't falling out. I can carefully pick up a load cartridge from my ammo box by the bullet, but if I shake it a little the case will drop off. It's at most a very, very light crimp. I do believe a neck sizing die is better.
I'm not a big fan of annealing because I don't FL size my brass. I have never annealed my .45-90 or .45-70 Starline brass, however many do. I had to anneal my .44-77 for fire forming but that is a different animal.
I like to seat my pp loads for target shooting very shallow, only about .080" in the case. I like my bullets to be a "snug" fit into a clean bore. I wipe between shots and the bore is very clean and dry after I do so. I use a water and oil mix for wiping. In competition I use bore pigs of my own making.
I don't like to get the leading edge of my patches too far forward on my bullets, usually about .020" back from the start of the ogive. All my molds are marked in some way to indicate where the patch should start.
I dry patch all my bullets, many wet patch, both ways work, but I find dry patching to be more consistent in the finish bullet. I size all my bullets after patching to a uniform fit in the bore of my each rifles using custom made sizing dies.
For me large pistol primers have worked best, but I usually start my development with Federal 210 large rifle primers. Not all rifles will work with pistol primers, mine do.
I have used .060" LDPE wads with best results except in my .45-90 where .060" HDPE wads gave the best accuracy. No idea why.
With Swiss 1 1/2, the only powder I use for serious target work, I usually have .080" to .100" compression. The exception would be a particular 2013 lot that wanted 3/16". The newer lots seem to like less compression again, but it can vary lot to lot. Some compression is necessary to keep the cartridge overall length uniform.
That's all I can think of for now. Answer a few question and I may be able to add something. Ask any question you have and I'll answer those if I can.
Other here may have more to add to loading pp in the .45-100. I have loaded pp in many other cases with good results using what I outline above. Each rifle is different and some time and experimentation is usually necessary to fine tune a pp load to a specific rifle.
In the end it seems not everybody can get paper patch to work well and I have no idea why some fail, it really is the easiest loading for BPCRs that I have ever done. It's almost too simple even when compared to greases. Really!